US Aid to Israel Becomes a Growing Political Issue

President Donald Trump

UNITED STATES: President Donald Trump is possibly the most supportive US president of Israel in recent times. So his Election Day announcement that the United States would stop giving Israel nearly $4 billion in yearly aid was surprising.

But, as often happens with Trump, the announcement made on Fox News lacked details and was hard to understand clearly. In practice, it may have less impact than the surprising announcement suggests.

Still, Trump’s move was another surprising change in his relationship with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu — his partner in the war with Iran, which could hurt Republican hopes in Tuesday’s midterm elections. It also comes at an important political moment. Israel is in political uncertainty after last week’s election produced no clear winner, leaving Netanyahu’s future uncertain.

The political situation in the US cannot be ignored. In a way, Trump seems to agree with Democrats such as Michigan Sen. Abdul El-Sayed that aid to Israel is becoming harder to support in US politics.

This shows a major split in the long-standing, shared support for Israel in Washington.

The issue goes beyond how a new Democratic House or Senate might handle it after Tuesday’s midterm elections. Trump’s announcement points to an uncertain future for Israel. Netanyahu has worked closely with Republicans in Washington across several administrations, but many people in Israel have criticized his response in Gaza to the Hamas attacks of October 7, 2023. This criticism has come not only from progressives but also from people on the right in Trump’s MAGA movement.

Growing doubts about whether Congress will support Israel and arms sales to its military could have major effects on Israel’s future and US policy in the Middle East.

Trump causes a stir on Election Day

Trump often makes surprising statements, draws attention to himself, and changes the subject. So perhaps his announcement in a Fox News interview was a political move on a day when many Republicans feared voters would strongly reject them.

The Fox hosts certainly seemed surprised.

“I have made a deal that we give Israel $4 billion a year, and we made a deal months ago that we’re stopping …. they’re fine with it because, you know, they’ve become a very successful country,” Trump said. He added that the US would help Israel if it needed support. “But by end of this year, we won’t be paying Israel.”

The president seemed to be talking about yearly US military aid to Israel. Under an agreement made during former President Barack Obama’s time in office in 2016, the aid is just under $4 billion a year. The agreement is set to continue until the end of 2028.

Most of the money is used to buy weapons and equipment for the Israeli military from US companies. So the agreement also affects US businesses and jobs. People are now looking at what future military cooperation between the US and Israel might involve. In January, Netanyahu told The Economist that he wanted to “gradually reduce” US military aid to Israel over 10 years and that the change was “in progress.”

It is unclear whether Trump meant that US aid would stop right away. That would be a major step, but it would not necessarily mean a serious break in the two countries’ relationship. Foreign policy experts who have worked for both Republican and Democratic administrations have said that Israel’s economy is now strong enough to buy military equipment without US aid. US weapons companies are still expected to do business with Israel, and the two countries’ militaries have worked more closely together recently than ever before. This was true even before the Iran war. For example, in 2024, the Biden administration carried out large air and sea defense operations to stop Iranian cruise missiles and drones.

Brett McGurk, who held senior White House and State Department roles under four presidents, said people often misunderstand US aid to Israel. “I wouldn’t overstate the significance” of Trump’s remarks on Tuesday, McGurk said.

“I don’t know whether he means we’ll end the agreement when it expires in 2028, or stop aid right now,” added McGurk, a CNN global affairs analyst and author of the new book Brink, about his part in talks to free hostages during the Gaza crisis.

Israel and the Palestinians are now US political issues

Trump made his announcement as tens of millions of Americans were voting. The election campaign showed how closely the Israel-Palestinian conflict is now tied to US politics.

It was surprising to hear Trump appear to respond to Democrats such as El-Sayed, who oppose US aid to Israel. Trump has often used insulting comments about El-Sayed’s Muslim faith. The Michigan Democrat has argued that Americans are paying more for groceries because the US is fighting a war for Israel.

“Why should we put up with attacks from people like El-Sayed when they (Israel) don’t need the money?” Trump told Fox & Friends. “It’s a bad argument because people would say, ‘Why don’t we give everyone $4 billion?’”

Reported By: Our Correspondent Reporter

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *